Wednesday, 27 November 2024

MALAYSIAN HOCKEY – DUE TO WEAK CALENDAR PLANNING CREATES CONFUSION & UNWANTED ISSUES

MALAYSIAN HOCKEY – DUE TO WEAK CALENDAR PLANNING CREATES CONFUSION & UNWANTED ISSUES

These few days or rather few years ago till today, the key issue about planning of proper one final calendar for hockey tournaments  which includes Affiliates, Domestic & International tournaments such as Field Hockey, Indoor Hockey & Hockey 5s for both genders Men & Women that is creating a confusion & arguments within the stakeholders.

This one final calendar is the duty of the Office to prepare at least an Olympic Cycle – means 2024 to 2028 and encompasses the Contingent Events – SEA, Asian Games, Commonwealth Games & Olympic with AHF – Continental events (Senior & Junior) and with FIH events such as World Cup, Qualifiers, Nation Cup, Sultan Azlan Shah Cup & Sultan of Johor Cup for both Senior & Junior activities and to top up any test matches, friendly or Invitational tournaments. To top it up – not including the periodization plan for national teams and the EB, EGM, AGM, Coaching Courses and TO, Umpires Courses and etc etec….Its requires a huge brainstorming activity.

When I was holding the Office, we had a clearly defined Calendar from 2009 till 2012 and it takes 3 months to come up with this “One Final Calendar – One Olympic Cycle” - from Affiliation/State, National & International with all courses & meeting dates - Council, Monthly EB, EGM/AGM with FIH/AHF Congress. This is a prerequisite for preparing the cost which is the Annual Budget and how to source the funds via grants and sponsorship.

Now is the crunch of the matters that I want to make the key points on the current problem in the press and community of hockey fans:

Looking at above details, how are they're going to fit in all the above arrangements, do the people in-charge aware of this consolidation of “one final calendar”. Currently, every Chairman of each SubCom decides when to organize domestic and which international event to play and for sure they will be no coordination as most players, Umpires, Technical resources will be overlapping between cross the board which will create the chaos. And all the good Umpires still serving their bans and most events using lower grade Umpiring which also created many wrong decision and Clubs or State were not satisfied with the quality of Umpiring. This is the Duty of Office & EB to endorse “One Final Calendar – One Olympic Cycle”.

Simple example – during last Razak Cup, Junior players & Indoor players couldn’t play because of SOJC24 & Indoor World Cup preparation. Why? No coordination between SubCom and ad-hoc calendar which created the unwanted issues. Many talks about the issue but due to poor planning created the chaos.

And now the debate of priority – Club for MHL or preparation with Indoor World Cup gets the players to play?

You knew that Indoor WC was in FEB 2025 after qualifying in May 2024 but yet nobody saw this because of working in silos. Working in silos means team members are isolated from the team itself. It could mean individuals or entire departments are isolated from the rest of the business. These individuals and groups don't collaborate with others, which can eventually lead to a lack of communication.

My view – it’s the CLUB/Employer that gets the first priority. This statement is always been used over the years even during our playing days. They are the actual paymaster and the future of national players depend on this Employment…

Even to make matter worst, currently, there not many Clubs/Organization providing jobs. On the above issues – 3 clubs are affected TNB, Maybank & UiTM.

Q-Are the players going lose their income by not playing in MHL? Will the Employer/Club decide not to release the players for national duties – one must understand that Employer decides on their leave to play for national team not the other way around….And do not use the word “Ban” as did to many top Umpires and also for this current dilemma – National team or Employer?

Just sharing in our playing days – we train Monday to Wednesday with national team and released to Club for MHL matches and even at some stage release to play KL League or any other state leagues that the player is involved. 

Bottom line – bread and butter are with the Club/Employer. National Team only provides basic allowances and priority is always the EMPLOYER!

You must understand that CLUBS & EMPLOYERS in hockey is not many in numbers anymore and hope this kind of issues will not hinder for the future employment for national players.

The actual fact is due to your poor planning and frequent ad-hoc decision that has brought this dilemma and please solve amicably so that these few Cubs don't stop supporting this sport which actual fact the cause of the problem is you and not the EMPLOYER… 

Please start planning for a detail “One Final Calendar – One Olympic Cycle 2024-2028” before it creates more future problems & the Employers may stop to support the game which not many left - even TNB & Maybank has gone to playing service contract compared to permanent job. Normally, during the MHL lah, for National or State players to do some cari makan on earnings to survive rather than working at Burger Shops, Family Mart, Petrol Kiosk or in Gig Economy as Riders. Lets have some little heart for these players to survive...

Actually, it’s a simple and doable Calendar…

If you need help, let me know will do it at no cost as its for national Interest…..only request – two cup of Teh-C hot one….

Monday, 25 November 2024

PERSONAL VIEW FROM MANINDERJIT SINGH (MIKE) ABOUT THE FUTURE OF MALAYSIAN HOCKEY & WHY ARE WE PLAYING BELOW PAR AT INTERNATIONAL EVENTS....

Warm Greetings to all my ardent readers...

For the last few years, Malaysian hockey underwent a massive turbulence with unrecoverable "air-pocket" tragedy in key major International Hockey Tournaments...

Been writing and saying the real cause on "why we are achieving below par performance" even though with massive transformation plan with many foreign consultants getting involved but yet we are sliding at World map and now even at Continental level...


Recently, there was a new initiative by Sportswriters Association of Malaysia (SAM) coming up with their own dedicated PODCAST called "SAM BANG" and posted on YOUTUBE Channel to share the insights on the views.

Interesting to see that - no censorship and the invitee is allowed to speak his mind without holding the real hard fact truth about the topic. As my requirement is always there should not be any narrative or personal agenda about the show, with that, I agreed to be part of this SAM BANG PODCAST few days ago...

Podcast SAMBANG bagi episod keenam SAM bersama Maninderjit Singh @ Mike 
Jam 10:00 malam | 19 November 2024 | Selasa

Topik - Status Malaysian Hockey dipentas Antarabangsa & peluang ke LA28

Please click the below link as there are 3 parts of the PODCAST...

Part 1


Part 2


Part 3


Just to be clear that whatever is said in the above 3 parts, the interest of the Nation & Sports was my first priority so that we are back to be in the Olympic Games after failing 6 Olympic Cycle since 2004 Athens till 2024 Paris.

Lucky as the most of FIH events the number of teams are expanded from the original 12 Teams to 16 Teams, even at Junior World Cup - is expanded from 16 to 24 teams and with that, the entry door is wider than those days and due to this expansion we are still playing at Senior & Junior World Cup. 

If the old 12 teams quota system remained, for sure we will be out of these events too as we have fallen badly and my assumption as of today the ranking in world hockey is stated below:

Senior Men Team - 16th or 17th
Jnr Men Team - 14th 
Senior Women Team - 23rd
Jnr Women Team - 19th  

And Malaysian Jnr Women team will also easily qualify due to 5 slots in Junior Asia Cup (decider with Thailand for 5th slot) which previously was only top 3 Asia Team when 16 team JWC. 

For Jnr Men at Asia level, 7 slots including India qualifies to 2025 JWC. Wait and see the results in 2025 JWC, it will a high scoring tournament due to 24 teams - many sub standard teams will be playing especially from Asia ranked 6-7 (Bangladesh, China, Thailand & Taipei), Oceania (PNG or Samoa will qualify) with Zimbabwe or Nigeria from Africa Continental. Many such teams are not ready for World Stage tournament...

I disagree on the expansion of teams, a World Cup is a World Cup, not every player or team could easily qualify to play in such events, the standards and competitive edge must be kept at the highest level possible and best teams keep pushing their benchmark.

Ideally, a Mini World Cup or like the new event call FIH Nation Cup 2 to provide a development team to use such events to grow at International level.

Thank you to all my readers and wishing everyone the very best..

Best Regards

Maninderjit Singh (Mike)
Double Olympian, Double World Cupper & Twice Asian All Star
Former SEC GEN of MHF & MHC

Friday, 8 November 2024

MALAYSIAN HOCKEY DILEMMA - Been invited for 3 Famous Renowned Podcast to Explain the Decay & Issues...Enjoy it!

Warm Greetings to all my readers...

Hope everyone has been good and fine. Didn't been writing for sometime and decided to just provide some updates and information.

Malaysian hockey is undergoing a unrepairable turbulence since last year  Asian Games till recent Sultan of Johor Cup 2024.

The Results based on the chronology of events:

2023 Asian Games - Finished 6th

2024 Paris Olympic Qualification in Jan Muscat - Finished 5th out of 8 teams

2024 Sultan Azlan Shah Cup - finished 4th out of 6

2024 FIH Nation Cup - finished 7 out of 8 teams - Poland played as a host.

2024 - Europe Tour Senior Team - Poor Performances

2024 Asian Champions Trophy - finished last 6 out of 6

2024 Junior Australia Tour - lost all the matches

2024 Sultan of Johor Cup - Men's U21 - Finished last 6 out of 6

What is a dilemma? - a difficult situation or problem.

The above results, in my view, I was expecting it and was not surprised, as this didn't happen overnight and its what we did in the last 6-8 years which is the real reflection of our standard in World Hockey. 

Many believed in perception over reality style of leadership but I was always consistent in my views and been saying that we are no longer an International Hockey Team but many defy my facts and but time & results has spoken..

Anyway, was called to be in two podcast lately to explain why and where was the decay or issues that is plaguing Malaysian hockey.

First was the RTM Sports Podcast as below link:

https://rtmklik.rtm.gov.my/play/program/spodcast/spodcastep63

2nd was - TIMESPORTS ON THE BEAT - WITH K RAJAN

https://open.spotify.com/episode/0ina7ELNW1xoUIB0ACP7ef?si=LfSDA_s_TV2_T_RMLG4kfw

3rd - latest with "SAM BANG" under the The Sportswriters Association of Malaysia (SAM) - will share the link once is online! Its HOT & SPICY!

Please enjoy both the above podcast links.....

Thanks to all the readers and support rendered...

Best Regards

Maninderjit Singh (Mike)

Former Malaysian Hockey Internationals